Should I Use a Permanent Life Insurance Policy Inside My Corporation in Ontario?
Learn when corporately owned permanent life insurance makes sense for an Ontario business owner and when it doesn't, with a worked example on a $1.2 million corporate portfolio. Explained by Marc Pineault, a retirement planner in London, Ontario.
By Marc Pineault, Retirement Planner in London, Ontario
Published
Permanent life insurance owned by your corporation can make sense in Ontario, but mainly when your company holds surplus money you won't need to live on and you have a lifelong reason to own insurance, such as paying the tax on your estate or leaving a set amount to your family. If you need that money for retirement income, or the premiums would strain the business, it is usually a poor fit. The answer depends on your corporation's surplus, your timeline and what you want your estate to do.
That's the short answer. The rest of this article covers how the strategy works, where it helps, where it causes trouble, and a worked example with real numbers. Marc Pineault, a retirement planner in London, Ontario, often gets this question from incorporated professionals and business owners who are starting to think about retirement.
Why corporations and permanent insurance come up together
Incorporated business owners in Ontario often build up money inside their company. The reason is the tax rate gap. According to the Canada Revenue Agency's corporation tax rates page, the first $500,000 of active business income for a Canadian-controlled private corporation qualifies for the small business deduction. Combined with Ontario's lower rate, that income is taxed at about 12.2%. Ontario's top personal marginal rate is about 53.53%.
Leaving profits in the company defers personal tax. But once that money is invested inside the corporation, it runs into two problems:
- High tax on investment income. Interest and other passive investment income earned in a Canadian-controlled private corporation in Ontario is taxed at roughly 50% at first. Part of that tax is refunded when dividends are paid out, but it is still a heavy drag while the money stays invested.
- The passive income grind. Under federal rules in place since 2019, the CRA reduces a corporation's $500,000 small business limit by $5 for every $1 of passive investment income above $50,000 a year. The limit reaches zero at $150,000 of passive income.
Permanent life insurance, such as whole life or universal life, is one of the few places where corporate money can grow without that annual tax, as long as the policy meets the "exempt policy" rules in the Income Tax Act. That's why it keeps coming up.
How a corporate-owned policy works
In the usual setup, the corporation owns the policy, pays the premiums and is the beneficiary. The business owner is the person insured.
Premiums
Premiums are generally not tax-deductible to the corporation. But they are paid with dollars taxed at the corporate rate, not the personal rate. If the same policy were owned personally, you would first pay yourself salary or dividends, pay personal tax on that, and then pay premiums with what's left. Paying with corporate dollars means less pre-tax income is needed to cover the same premium.
Growth inside the policy
In a participating whole life policy or a universal life policy, part of each premium builds cash value. As long as the policy stays exempt, that growth isn't taxed each year. Because it isn't taxed, it doesn't count toward the corporation's adjusted aggregate investment income. That is the figure behind the $50,000 passive income threshold.
The payout at death and the capital dividend account
When the insured person dies, the corporation receives the death benefit tax-free. The amount of the death benefit above the policy's adjusted cost basis (ACB) is credited to the corporation's capital dividend account (CDA). The corporation can then pay out the CDA balance to shareholders or the estate as a tax-free capital dividend.
The ACB of a policy usually rises in the early years and then falls over time, often reaching zero in later life. So the longer the policy is held, the more of the death benefit can usually come out of the corporation tax-free.
This is the main reason corporate ownership appeals to people. Without the insurance, getting the same amount out of a corporation after death would usually mean paying taxable dividends.
Where corporate-owned permanent insurance tends to fit
This strategy suits a fairly narrow group. It tends to fit owners who:
- Have surplus corporate money. This is money the business doesn't need and you won't need for retirement income.
- Have a permanent need for insurance. For example, there may be a large tax bill at death from the deemed sale of the company shares, a cottage or investments, or you may want to leave a set amount to children or a charity.
- Are near or above the $50,000 passive income threshold, or expect to be within a few years.
- Are insurable at reasonable rates. Health, age and smoking status drive the cost.
- Have a long time horizon. These policies usually need many years of premiums and growth before the numbers work well.
It is usually a weaker fit when the corporate money is really your retirement fund. If you plan to draw on the corporation through salary or dividends in your 60s, the money you put into a policy is money you can't easily spend. How you take money out of the company matters a lot here, and our salary vs dividends guide explains how those choices affect your tax and your retirement.
A worked example on a $1.2 million corporate portfolio
The numbers below are rounded and only illustrate the mechanics. They are not a projection for any person or policy.
The setup. An Ontario corporation earns $500,000 a year of active business income and holds $1,200,000 in a corporate investment account.
Step 1: Passive income. Say the portfolio earns 5% a year that counts as investment income: $1,200,000 × 5% = $60,000 of passive income.
Step 2: The grind. That's $10,000 over the $50,000 threshold. $10,000 × $5 = $50,000 reduction to the small business limit. The limit drops from $500,000 to $450,000.
Step 3: The added corporate tax. The $50,000 that no longer gets the small business rate is now taxed at Ontario's combined general corporate rate of about 26.5%, instead of about 12.2%. 26.5% − 12.2% = 14.3% $50,000 × 14.3% = about $7,150 more corporate tax that year.
Some of this comes back through Canada's integration system, because income taxed at the general rate can later be paid out as eligible dividends, which are taxed at a lower personal rate. But it still means less money stays invested in the meantime.
Step 4: Moving part of the surplus into a policy. Now say $300,000 of that surplus goes into an exempt permanent policy over several years instead of the investment account. The remaining $900,000 earning 5% produces: $900,000 × 5% = $45,000 of passive income, which is under the $50,000 threshold. The full $500,000 small business limit is kept.
Step 5: At death. Say the policy pays a $1,500,000 death benefit and its ACB at that time is $200,000. $1,500,000 − $200,000 = $1,300,000 credited to the capital dividend account and payable tax-free. The other $200,000 would generally come out as a taxable dividend.
What the example doesn't show. The insurance has costs, so the policy's cash value usually grows more slowly than an investment account at the same rate of return, especially in the early years. Money in a policy is also less flexible. For this to work, the tax savings and the estate benefit have to outweigh those costs. That only becomes clear when you model your own numbers over decades. The free retirement planning calculators can help you see how your wider retirement income picture fits together before you look at insurance.
The trade-offs people underestimate
It is a long commitment
Many permanent policies are built to be held for life. Surrender charges, slow early cash value growth and premium schedules can make it costly to change your mind in the first ten or more years.
Getting money out while you're alive is awkward
The cash value belongs to the corporation. Withdrawing it or surrendering the policy can create a taxable policy gain inside the company. Some owners plan to use the policy as collateral for a loan in retirement. That approach depends on future lending rules, interest rates and the policy's performance, and none of those are certain. It should be treated as a possibility, not a plan.
Ownership and beneficiary details matter
If the corporation pays premiums on a policy that you own personally, or the beneficiary designations don't match who owns the policy, the CRA may treat it as a taxable shareholder benefit. Setups with a holding company, an operating company and more than one shareholder need extra care. A shareholders' agreement may also refer to insurance used to fund a buyout, and it needs to match how the policy is set up.
Rules can change
The exempt policy test was rewritten for policies issued from 2017 onward, and the passive income rules arrived in 2019. Tax policy for private corporations has changed several times in the past decade, and a strategy that depends on current rules carries that risk.
Licensing and suitability
In Ontario, life insurance agents are licensed and supervised by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). Before a permanent policy is sold, an agent is expected to assess whether it suits your needs. You can ask how the recommendation compares with simpler options, such as term insurance plus investing the difference inside the corporation.
Questions to ask before deciding
Marc Pineault puts it simply:
"I want to know what the money is for before we talk about the policy. If that corporate surplus is your retirement paycheque, insurance is usually the wrong place for it. If it's money for your kids or the tax bill on your estate, it's worth a closer look."
— Marc Pineault, retirement planner in London, Ontario
A few questions help clarify things:
- How much corporate money will you actually need to fund retirement, including your CPP, OAS and registered savings?
- Is there a tax bill at death or a legacy goal that won't go away?
- Is your corporation near the $50,000 passive income threshold now, or will it be soon?
- Could the premiums be paid comfortably for the full schedule, even in a slow year for the business?
- What happens to the policy if the business is sold, wound up or passed to family?
How the corporate money fits with your personal accounts matters too. For example, the order in which you draw down an RRSP or RRIF changes how much corporate surplus you really have. Our RRIF withdrawal strategy guide covers that side of retirement income.
The bottom line
Corporate-owned permanent life insurance is a tool for a specific job: moving surplus corporate money to the next generation, or to the tax bill at death, with less tax and less passive income drag along the way. It works best when the money truly is surplus and the need for insurance truly is permanent. It works poorly when it ties up money you'll need to live on.
For business owners around London, Ontario, the useful first step is a clear picture of how much your corporation will need to pay you in retirement. Once that's settled, it becomes much easier to see whether any money is left over for an insurance strategy, and whether it would help.
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial advice. Please consult a qualified professional before making any financial decisions.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. If the corporation owns the policy and is the beneficiary, it can pay the premiums with after-tax corporate dollars. The premiums are generally not tax-deductible, but they are paid with money taxed at the lower corporate rate.
When the corporation receives the death benefit, the amount above the policy's adjusted cost basis is added to its capital dividend account. The corporation can then pay that amount to shareholders or the estate as a tax-free capital dividend.
Growth inside an exempt life insurance policy is generally not taxed each year, so it is not counted as passive investment income. That is why some business owners look at it when their corporate investments get close to the $50,000 threshold.
Cancelling the policy can create a taxable gain inside the corporation if the cash surrender value is more than the policy's adjusted cost basis. Early surrender charges in some policies can also mean getting back less than was paid in.
In most cases, yes. It tends to fit owners whose corporations hold surplus money they won't need for their lifestyle and who have a lasting need for insurance, such as covering taxes at death or leaving money to heirs.
More articles on this topic: Corp planning →
Marc Pineault
Retirement Planner in London, Ontario
I help families and business owners in London, Ontario build clear financial plans for retirement, taxes, and investments — then I manage it all and keep the plan current as life changes.
Learn more about me →Enjoyed this article?
Get the next one in your inbox. Financial planning tips from Marc Pineault — practical, Ontario-specific, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
