GIC vs TFSA: Why a GIC Inside Your TFSA Can Cost You
A TFSA is the account and a GIC is one thing you can hold in it. Here is why putting low-yield GICs in your TFSA can use up your most valuable tax-free room, with a worked Ontario example.
By Marc Pineault, Retirement Planner in London, Ontario
Published · Updated
A GIC and a TFSA are not competitors. A TFSA is the account, and a GIC is one of many things you can hold inside it. The real question is what belongs in your TFSA, and for long-term money a low-yield GIC can use up tax-free room that would likely compound more over time with growth investments.
That doesn't make GICs bad. It means where you hold them matters a great deal. Below I explain how GIC interest is taxed, when a GIC fits inside a TFSA, when it doesn't, and how the same total mix of safe and growth money can produce very different results depending on which account holds what.
The GIC Question I Hear Every Week
"GIC rates are still decent. Why would I risk my money in the market?"
It's a fair question, and I hear it often from people across London, Ontario. When rates climbed to 5 percent and above in 2023 and 2024, many savers grew attached to Guaranteed Investment Certificates. The appeal is clear: a known return, protected principal, and no worrying about what the stock market does tomorrow.
The rate picture has changed since then. According to the Bank of Canada, the policy interest rate fell from 5 percent in mid-2024 to 2.25 percent by late 2025. GIC yields followed it down, and renewal offers today are well below the peaks many savers got used to.
Lower GIC rates make the question of which account holds them more important, not less.
TFSA Basics: The Account, Not the Investment
The Tax-Free Savings Account is a registered account. Anything inside it grows tax-free, and withdrawals are not taxed and do not count as income. According to the Canada Revenue Agency's TFSA page, the 2026 annual limit is $7,000. Someone who has been eligible since 2009 and never contributed has $109,000 of total room.
Inside a TFSA you can hold cash, GICs, bonds, individual stocks, exchange-traded funds and mutual funds. Opening a "TFSA" at a bank counter often defaults to a savings account or a GIC, and many people assume that's simply what a TFSA is. It isn't. The account is the container, and you choose what goes in it.
That room is limited and personal, so the choice matters. Every dollar of TFSA room holding a 3 percent investment is a dollar that isn't holding something with higher expected long-term growth.
How GIC Interest Is Taxed Outside Registered Accounts
Outside a TFSA or RRSP, GIC interest gets the least favourable tax treatment of the three main kinds of investment income in Canada.
Interest income (GICs, savings accounts, bonds): 100 percent of the interest is added to your taxable income each year, even on a multi-year GIC that hasn't matured yet. For many middle-income Ontarians, the combined federal-provincial marginal rate is roughly 30 percent, so you keep about 70 cents of every interest dollar. Current rates are on the CRA's tax rates pages.
Capital gains (stocks, ETFs, real estate): Only 50 percent of a capital gain is included in taxable income. At a 30 percent marginal rate, the effective tax on a gain is about 15 percent, and it's paid only when you sell.
Canadian eligible dividends: Because of the dividend tax credit, eligible dividends from Canadian public companies are taxed at a noticeably lower rate than interest for most Ontario taxpayers.
Interest has one more drawback for retirees. Every dollar of it counts toward net income, which can push income toward the Old Age Security recovery threshold. Our OAS clawback strategy guide explains how that threshold works. This is also why GIC decisions belong inside tax planning, not beside it.
The Inflation Problem: Are You Actually Making Money?
Even before tax, it's worth asking whether a GIC keeps up with rising prices.
The Bank of Canada targets 2 percent inflation. According to Statistics Canada, the Consumer Price Index rose 2.4 percent on an annual average basis in 2024, down from 6.8 percent in 2022.
Take a 3.5 percent GIC and 2.5 percent inflation. The real return is about 1 percent before tax. In a non-registered account at a 30 percent marginal rate, the after-tax return falls to about 2.45 percent, which is below inflation. Your purchasing power shrinks.
Over 20 years, $100,000 growing at 1 percent real becomes about $122,000 in today's dollars. The same $100,000 growing at 4 to 5 percent real, which is roughly the long-run historical range for diversified equity portfolios, would become about $219,000 to $265,000. Past returns don't predict future ones, but over decades the gap from compounding is large.
When a GIC Inside a TFSA Makes Sense
I'm not anti-GIC. A GIC in a TFSA can be a sensible choice in several situations.
Money you'll need within one to three years
Maybe you're saving for a vehicle, a roof, or a down payment for a child. Or maybe you've received an inheritance and want time to think. In those cases, certainty matters more than growth. A market drop just before you need the money is a real risk.
Your TFSA is your only account
If you have no RRSP, RRIF or non-registered account, there's nowhere else to hold your safe money. The question then becomes how much of the TFSA should be safe, not which account should hold the GICs.
Low-income retirees and the Guaranteed Income Supplement
For retirees who receive or may qualify for the Guaranteed Income Supplement, TFSA withdrawals don't count as income. Keeping safe money in the TFSA can protect benefits that RRIF withdrawals might reduce.
You genuinely can't tolerate market swings
If market drops would lead you to sell at the bottom, a higher safe allocation may suit you, even if it isn't the best mathematically. The best plan is the one you can stick with.
When a GIC in Your TFSA Can Cost You
For money with a horizon of ten years or more, a TFSA holding mostly GICs carries a quiet cost: tax-free room you can't get back.
Because TFSA growth is never taxed, every extra percentage point of return there is kept in full. The TFSA is often the best home for the investments you expect to grow the most. GICs can usually sit in an RRSP or RRIF instead, where interest isn't taxed each year either and is simply taxed as income when withdrawn, like everything else in that account.
"Most people I meet don't have a GIC problem, they have a placement problem. The question usually isn't whether to own GICs, it's which account they sit in," says Marc Pineault, retirement planner in London, Ontario.
A Worked Example: Same Mix, Different Accounts
Here is an illustration for a retired couple in London with a $1,000,000 portfolio. It is not a projection for any real household. The return figures are assumptions chosen to show the math.
Their accounts:
- $600,000 in RRIFs
- $200,000 across two TFSAs
- $200,000 in a non-registered account
Their goal: Keep 30 percent, or $300,000, in GICs for stability, with the rest in a diversified portfolio.
Arrangement A, GICs in the TFSAs first:
- $200,000 of GICs in the TFSAs
- $100,000 of GICs in the RRIFs
- The growth portfolio is spread across the remaining RRIF and non-registered money
Arrangement B, GICs in the RRIFs:
- $300,000 of GICs in the RRIFs
- The TFSAs hold growth investments
Both couples own exactly $300,000 of GICs and $700,000 of growth investments. Only the account locations differ.
Step 1: TFSA growth under Arrangement A. $200,000 at an assumed 3.5 percent for 20 years: $200,000 × 1.035²⁰ = $200,000 × 1.990 ≈ $398,000.
Step 2: TFSA growth under Arrangement B. $200,000 at an assumed 6 percent for 20 years: $200,000 × 1.06²⁰ = $200,000 × 3.207 ≈ $641,000.
Step 3: The difference. About $243,000 more is sitting in the TFSAs, and all of it can be withdrawn tax-free.
Step 4: What offsets it. Under Arrangement B, more growth sits in the RRIFs and less in the TFSAs. RRIF dollars are taxed when withdrawn, while TFSA dollars never are. The net benefit is therefore smaller than $243,000 once taxes on the other accounts are counted, but it typically leans in Arrangement B's favour. Real returns will vary, and a bad decade early on would narrow the gap.
How withdrawals come out of those RRIFs matters as well. Our RRIF withdrawal strategy guide covers that side. To test your own figures, try the free retirement planning calculators.
GIC Laddering If You Do Use GICs
If GICs fit part of your plan, a ladder spreads them across maturity dates. With $100,000, a simple five-year ladder holds $20,000 each in one-, two-, three-, four- and five-year GICs. Each year one matures and can be renewed into a new five-year term.
A ladder helps in three ways:
- Less reinvestment risk. Only one-fifth renews at whatever rate applies that year.
- Regular access. Some money is never more than 12 months from maturity.
- Smoother returns. Your blended rate mixes several terms instead of one rate locked at one point in time.
Remember too that the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation covers eligible deposits up to $100,000 per member institution in each insured category. TFSAs, RRSPs and RRIFs are each separate categories. Laddering is a useful tactic, but it doesn't fix low real returns or the tax treatment of interest in a non-registered account.
A Common Framework: Time Buckets
Many households sort their money by when they'll need it:
Short-term money (one to three years): GICs, high-interest savings, or cashable GICs. This includes the emergency fund and near-term spending.
Medium-term money (three to seven years): A conservative mix of short-term bonds, GICs and a modest share of stocks.
Long-term money (seven years or more): A diversified portfolio, mostly stocks, with fixed income as ballast.
A retiree drawing income might keep two to three years of planned withdrawals in the short-term bucket. They can then draw from it during market downturns instead of selling investments while prices are low. Getting the overall structure right matters more than any single product. Costs matter too, and our article on investment fees explains how they add up over a retirement. The same short-term-versus-long-term reasoning also comes up when people weigh paying off a mortgage or investing.
The All-GIC Retirement Risk
The costliest pattern I see is a retiree moving everything to GICs at 60 or 65 to "play it safe." Retirement can last 25 to 35 years. At 2.5 percent inflation, purchasing power roughly halves over 28 years, so a $60,000 lifestyle today would cost about $120,000 in 2054.
GICs remove market swings, but they bring a different risk: running short because the portfolio doesn't grow enough to keep up with withdrawals over a long life. The order of returns stops mattering, but the shortfall risk can be the bigger one.
Making Sense of Your Own Situation
The GIC-versus-investing question has no universal answer. It depends on:
- Time horizon. Money needed soon suits GICs. Money needed in ten or more years usually suits a diversified portfolio.
- Account type. Non-registered GIC interest is taxed most heavily. Inside registered accounts the tax issue goes away, but the growth trade-off remains.
- Benefits. Interest income can affect OAS and GIS.
- Comfort with volatility. A plan you abandon in a downturn helps no one.
If you're unsure how your TFSA fits with your RRSP, the RRSP vs TFSA Ontario guide is a good starting point.
Looking at Your Numbers
If you have GICs coming up for renewal, or cash you're unsure where to place, it helps to look at them as part of your whole picture. Marc Pineault is a retirement planner in London, Ontario who helps people with account placement, registered-account strategy and investment management.
Book a Retirement Consultation and bring your GIC statements, your latest Notice of Assessment and your account details. We'll look at the after-tax, after-inflation picture together. If your GICs already suit your plan, I'll say so.
Related reading: RRSP vs TFSA: Ontario Decision Guide, Are Your Investment Fees Costing You $300,000?, and Mortgage Payoff vs. Investing. You can also take the Retirement Readiness Quiz.
Frequently asked questions
No. A TFSA is a type of account, and a GIC is one of the investments you can hold inside it, alongside things like cash, bonds, stocks and funds.
Not always. A GIC in a TFSA makes sense for money you will need within a few years, but long-term money there may be giving up tax-free growth that can never be recovered.
The CRA set the 2026 TFSA annual limit at $7,000. Someone who has been eligible since 2009 and never contributed has $109,000 of total room.
GIC interest in a non-registered account is fully taxable every year at your marginal rate, even if the GIC has not matured. For many middle-income Ontarians, that means roughly 30 cents of every interest dollar goes to tax.
Many retirees hold their GICs in an RRSP or RRIF, where interest is not taxed each year, and keep higher-growth investments in the TFSA. The right mix depends on your timeline, income needs and comfort with ups and downs.
Marc Pineault
Retirement Planner in London, Ontario
I help families and business owners in London, Ontario build clear financial plans for retirement, taxes, and investments — then I manage it all and keep the plan current as life changes.
Learn more about me →Enjoyed this article?
Get the next one in your inbox. Financial planning tips from Marc Pineault — practical, Ontario-specific, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
