Retirement10 min read

Drawdown Order: RRSP First or Non-Registered First in Retirement?

Not sure whether to draw from your RRSP or non-registered account first in retirement? This guide breaks down the tax trade-offs every Ontario retiree should understand — with insight from Marc Pineault, a retirement planner in London, Ontario.

MP

By Marc Pineault, Retirement Planner in London, Ontario

Published · Updated

Neither account is the right first choice for everyone, and for most Ontario retirees the better answer is a blend that changes from year to year. RRSP money is often worth drawing in low-income years before CPP, OAS and RRIF minimums stack up, while non-registered money tends to be useful when your income is already high, because only part of each withdrawal is taxed. The order can change how much tax you pay over a 20 or 30-year retirement, so it is worth understanding the trade-offs before you settle on a rule.

Why the Order You Draw From Accounts Matters

Every dollar you pull out of an RRSP, or a RRIF, which your RRSP must convert to by the end of the year you turn 71, is fully taxable as ordinary income in the year you take it. Selling investments in a non-registered account works differently. Part of what you receive is your own original money, which isn't taxed at all, and only half of the gain is added to your income. The Department of Finance confirmed in Budget 2025 that the proposed increase to that rate would not go ahead.

Interest earned in a non-registered account is the exception. It is fully taxable every year, whether or not you withdraw anything.

This asymmetry is why the order matters. Drawing from the wrong account at the wrong time can push you into a higher tax bracket, reduce your Old Age Security benefit through the clawback, or create a much larger tax bill at death than your family is expecting.

The brackets show how much room there is to work with. According to the CRA's 2026 tax rates, the combined federal and Ontario rate is 19.05% on taxable income up to $53,891, and 29.65% on income between $58,523 and $107,785, before Ontario's surtax. That gap is the reason timing can matter as much as the amount.

The Case for Drawing from Your RRSP Earlier

Many retirees in Canada stop working in their early to mid-sixties, before CPP and OAS begin. This window, often somewhere between age 60 and 70, is frequently a lower-income period when your marginal tax rate may be the lowest it will be in retirement.

Drawing from your RRSP during this window means paying tax at a lower rate than you might face later, when CPP, OAS, and mandatory RRIF minimums all stack on top of each other. This approach is sometimes called an "RRSP meltdown," and the goal is to smooth your income over time rather than face a spike later. Our RRSP meltdown guide walks through it in more detail.

The RRIF rules are what make the later years less flexible. According to the CRA's prescribed factors, the minimum withdrawal is 5.28% of the account for someone who was 71 at the start of the year, 5.82% at 75 and 6.82% at 80. Every $100,000 taken out earlier therefore means $5,400 less in required income at age 72, using that year's 5.40% factor, though it also means less money left growing inside the plan. The RRIF withdrawal strategy guide covers how those minimums work.

There's also an estate planning angle. When you pass away without a surviving spouse or a financially dependent child, your entire RRSP or RRIF balance is generally treated as income in the year of death. On a $600,000 RRIF with no other income that year, more than half of the balance would sit above $258,482, where the CRA's federal 33% and Ontario 13.16% rates apply. With Ontario's surtax, that comes to about 53.5%.

One Ontario-specific point is worth knowing here. According to the Ontario government, Estate Administration Tax is $15 per $1,000 of estate value for estates above $50,000, and a registered account with a named beneficiary generally passes outside the estate. So the income tax on a RRIF and the probate cost on other accounts are separate questions.

The Case for Drawing from Non-Registered Accounts First

If your non-registered account holds investments with significant built-in capital gains, withdrawing from it forces you to realize those gains. In a year when your income is already high, that can be expensive. In a lower-income year, triggering a capital gain is far more manageable and may be taxed at a lower effective rate.

Holding non-registered investments longer means you keep deferring the capital gain. Meanwhile, your RRSP continues to grow on a tax-sheltered basis, which has value over a long time horizon.

If your non-registered account is heavy in interest-generating investments, such as GICs, bonds, or high-interest savings, those produce fully taxable income every year regardless of whether you withdraw anything. In that case, drawing down non-registered assets first can reduce your annual tax bill even before you touch a dollar of your RRSP.

The Role of TFSA Withdrawals and the OAS Clawback

Most retirement drawdown plans in Canada involve three account types: RRSP or RRIF, non-registered, and TFSA. TFSA withdrawals are tax-free and do not count as income, including for the OAS clawback calculation. The CRA adds the amount you withdraw back to your room the following January, on top of the new dollar limit, which is $7,000 for 2026. For that reason, drawing TFSA funds last, or using them selectively to fill income gaps, is a strategy worth understanding.

The OAS clawback, formally called the OAS pension recovery tax, begins once your net income crosses a threshold the federal government adjusts each year. According to the Government of Canada's recovery tax page, that threshold is $95,323 for 2026 income, and you repay 15% of your income above it. The full pension is gone at about $155,320 for ages 65 to 74 and $161,320 for ages 75 and over.

To put that in context, the Government of Canada lists the maximum OAS pension for October to December 2026 at $762.50 a month for ages 65 to 74 and $838.75 a month for ages 75 and over. For retirees with large RRSP or RRIF balances, uncoordinated withdrawals can cost a meaningful part of that income. Our OAS clawback strategy guide looks at this threshold more closely.

A Worked Example: One $50,000 Withdrawal, Three Accounts

Here is a simplified illustration, using made-up numbers and 2026 rules. It is not a projection or a suggestion for any particular person.

Picture a 72-year-old single Ontario retiree with a $1,200,000 portfolio:

  • RRIF: $700,000
  • Non-registered account: $400,000, with an original cost of $250,000
  • TFSA: $100,000

This person already has $80,000 of net income from their RRIF minimum, CPP, OAS and a small pension. They need another $50,000 this year for a new roof and a car.

Option 1: The RRIF

  1. The full $50,000 is added to income, which brings net income to $130,000.
  2. Income above the OAS threshold is $130,000 minus $95,323, or $34,677.
  3. The OAS repayment is 15% of $34,677, or about $5,202. That is more than half of a pension worth roughly $9,000 a year.
  4. Income tax also applies to the $50,000, at combined rates of 29.65% to 37.16% before Ontario's surtax.

Option 2: The Non-Registered Account

  1. Gains make up 37.5% of the account, which is $150,000 divided by $400,000.
  2. Selling $50,000 of a proportional mix realizes a gain of 37.5% of $50,000, or $18,750. The other $31,250 is original cost.
  3. Half of the gain, $9,375, is added to income, which brings net income to $89,375.
  4. That is $5,948 below the threshold, so there is no OAS repayment.

Option 3: The TFSA

  1. Nothing is added to income, so net income stays at $80,000.
  2. There is no OAS repayment and no tax on the withdrawal.
  3. The $50,000 of room comes back the following January.

In this single year, the RRIF looks like the most expensive source. That isn't the whole picture, though. The RRIF is still there, its minimums continue, and it remains fully taxable later, possibly at a much higher rate on a final return. Had the same person drawn more from the RRSP in their mid-sixties, while their income was lower, the $80,000 starting point might have been smaller to begin with. A one-year answer and a lifetime answer can point in different directions.

Ontario Details That Can Change the Answer

A few other items often affect the decision for Ontario households:

  • Pension income splitting. From age 65, RRIF income can generally be split with a spouse, up to 50%, on your tax returns. RRSP withdrawals don't qualify, which is one reason some people move a portion to a RRIF at 65.
  • The pension income amount. Eligible pension income, including RRIF income from age 65, can support a federal credit on up to $2,000 a year.
  • The Ontario Health Premium. This is charged through your tax return and rises with taxable income, up to $900 a year.
  • CPP and OAS timing. Delaying these benefits leaves more low-income years for RRSP withdrawals, while also raising the later payments. The CPP timing guide explains the trade-off.
  • Withholding tax. According to the CRA's withholding rates, a lump-sum RRSP withdrawal above $15,000 has 30% withheld. That is a prepayment, not your final tax, so it can make a withdrawal look more or less costly than it really is.

The Real Answer: A Year-by-Year Strategy

For most Ontarians, the better drawdown order is not "RRSP first" or "non-registered first" as a blanket rule applied for life. It is a blend that shifts from year to year based on your income, your account balances, your age, your tax bracket, and any income-tested benefits you receive or may receive.

A common approach is to draw from an RRSP or RRIF in amounts that keep income just below a critical threshold: the top of a lower tax bracket, the OAS clawback trigger, or the income limit for benefits like the Guaranteed Income Supplement. Filling those brackets deliberately each year, rather than reactively, is how retirees typically aim to reduce lifetime taxes rather than only this year's bill.

"I look at the tax bill for the whole retirement and the estate, not just this year. A withdrawal that looks expensive at 66 can be the one that makes age 80 much easier."

— Marc Pineault, retirement planner in London, Ontario

Marc Pineault, a retirement planner in London, Ontario, works with retirees and pre-retirees to model different drawdown sequences and see how each one plays out over time. The math is personal, because it depends on your numbers, your household situation, and your goals. Our free retirement planning calculators are one way to start testing your own figures.

If you are within five to ten years of retirement, or already in it, your drawdown order is worth a careful look. You can book a Retirement Consultation with Marc to talk through how the accounts in your situation fit together.

Frequently asked questions

There's no single right answer, because it depends on your income, tax bracket, and account balances each year. Many retirees end up using a blend of both, timed around thresholds like the OAS clawback line, rather than a fixed rule.

It can be, if your income is low in early retirement before CPP and OAS begin, because those withdrawals may be taxed at a lower rate than later RRIF minimums. This approach is sometimes called an RRSP meltdown, and it doesn't suit everyone.

RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income, and for 2026 you repay 15 cents of OAS for every dollar of net income above $95,323. The repayment grows until the full pension is gone at about $155,320 for ages 65 to 74.

A common pattern is to draw RRSP or RRIF money in lower-income years, use non-registered money where the tax on gains is manageable, and keep the TFSA for later or for income gaps. TFSA withdrawals are tax-free and don't affect income-tested benefits.

If no surviving spouse or financially dependent child inherits it, the full RRSP or RRIF balance is generally treated as income on your final tax return. A large balance can be taxed at Ontario's top rate of about 53.5%.

More articles on this topic: Retirement planning →

MP

Marc Pineault

Retirement Planner in London, Ontario

I help families and business owners in London, Ontario build clear financial plans for retirement, taxes, and investments — then I manage it all and keep the plan current as life changes.

Learn more about me →
retirement plannerontariolondon ontariomarc pineault

Enjoyed this article?

Get the next one in your inbox. Financial planning tips from Marc Pineault — practical, Ontario-specific, no spam.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related Articles

See where your retirement actually stands

Nine questions, about two minutes, then a clear next step from Marc Pineault, Retirement Planner in London, Ontario.

Prefer to talk first? Book a Retirement Consultation →

Or call me at 519-281-2735 or text 226-242-3640.